Offset of Damages in Medical Malpractice Cases Under the Military Claims Act

By Julius Reyes, Fort Bliss Legal Assistance Office

Medical malpractice cases involving military personnel can be complex, especially when it comes to the compensation process. The Military Claims Act serves as a legal framework for military personnel to seek compensation for injuries, including those resulting from medical malpractice. It provides an avenue for Soldiers to file claims against the government for negligent acts or omissions by military medical professionals. The Act acknowledges that military doctors, nurses, and other healthcare providers can make mistakes, and it aims to ensure that injured personnel receive fair compensation.

 One crucial aspect of the MCA that Soldiers need to be aware of is the provision that allows the Department of Defense or the Department of Veterans Affairs to offset compensation. This means that if a Soldier successfully files a claim for medical malpractice and later receives compensation from another source, such as VA disability benefits or a settlement from a lawsuit against a civilian medical provider, the amount awarded under the MCA may be reduced accordingly. This offset provision is designed to prevent double recovery and ensure that Soldiers are not overcompensated for the same harm.

 While the intent behind the offset provision may be logical, it can lead to some challenges and potential inequities. One concern is that Soldiers may feel discouraged from pursuing claims under the MCA if they fear that any compensation received from other sources will be offset, diminishing their overall recovery. This could lead to a reluctance to seek justice for medical malpractice incidents, impacting the accountability of military medical professionals.

Additionally, determining how much compensation should be offset can be a complex process. Factors such as the nature and extent of the injuries, the timing of the compensation received, and the specific laws and regulations governing the various sources of compensation can all come into play. It requires careful consideration to ensure fairness and to prevent under-compensation or overcompensation.

 The offset provision in the Military Claims Act presents a unique challenge for military personnel seeking compensation for medical malpractice. While it aims to prevent double recovery, it also raises concerns about discouraging claims and potential inequities. A balanced approach that considers the interests of injured Soldiers and the need for accountability in military healthcare is essential. While this possible offset should not discourage Soldiers from bringing cases seeking damages for medical malpractice under the MCA, it is best for Soldiers to do so with an awareness that the amount of these damages could possibly be lowered at some point in the future.

If you have any further questions on identity theft, please schedule an appointment to speak with an attorney at Fort Bliss Legal Assistance Office by either calling (915) 568-7141 during office hours or emailing anytime.